AVSIM Commercial Scenery Review

KDEN (Denver)

KDTW (Detroit)

 

Rating Guide
Publisher: Imagine Simulation
Description:  Two separate scenery packages for Denver, CO and Detroit, MI
Download Size:
29MB/39MB
Format:
Download Only
Simulation Type:
Scenery for FS 2002 & FS 2004
Reviewed by: Cameron Jones AVSIM Staff Reviewer

The AVSIM Commercial Rating System: 1 Star to 5 Stars (with 5 stars being exceptional) Please see details of our review rating policy here .

About The Airports

KDEN
The Denver International Airport, when compared to other airports, is very young. It was built on 34,000 acres of land in 1995; the airport at the time of writing is just ten years old and remains one of the biggest airports in the world. It was constructed to replace the aging Denver airport known as Stapleton, which was forced closed upon the opening of the new airport. Passengers flying in and out of Denver are able to enjoy the huge Jeppesen Terminal and its many amenities. The airport also features three separate airside concourses that are accessible by train only. Perhaps the most exciting and memorable feature of the airport is the stunning and unique roof design. The roof is made of 15 acres of Telfon-coated woven fiber glass and covers the terminal’s “Great Hall.” The airport also features a total of six runways, the biggest being an amazing 16,000 feet long. This runway is able to accommodate any size of aircraft during a warm summer day in the mile high city.

KDTW
The Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport is much older then Denver, however, it is currently undergoing a huge construction project to expand and modernize the airport. This project is scheduled to be fully completed in 2008. DTW is situated on 6,700 acres (dramatically smaller then Denver) and is the 10th busiest airport in the United States. Like Denver, Detroit also has a total of six runways, the largest of which is 12,001 feet long. The airport features three terminals, which includes a brand new 97 gate terminal for Northwest Airlines who has a hub in Detroit. Many other airlines operate in and out of Detroit, such as Continental, Delta, Lufthansa, Air Canada and United to name only a few.

Such large airports like these certainly require a lot of hard work and a talented team to recreate them in flight simulator and Imagine Simulation was up to the task.

Download, Installation and Documentation

The Denver and Detroit scenery are both available strictly by download. The Denver scenery is 29MB and the Detroit package is 39MB. On broadband you can expect to see good speeds from the server and it took just less then 2 minutes to download each of these packages. On dialup the download should take less then 2 hours. The packages are delivered in the secure Flight1 Wrapper which allows you to purchase the sceneries after the download is complete.

The installation was quick and simple. You are presented with two executable installer files, one for FS2002 and one for FS2004. After running the appropriate file you are asked for your installation key, and although the key is long, you can easily cut and paste the key or select the text file that contains your key and it will automatically be filled in for you. When the key is entered correctly the installation begins. Once all the files are copied over, the installer will create the entries into the scenery.cfg file and create a back up of the old file in the unlikely event that something goes wrong. Once this is done, your scenery is ready to use. If you’re like me you’ll just want to jump in and explore for a bit. Others may rather read the included documentation before heading off to the airport.

Imagine Simulation has provided a 16 page PDF file for Denver and a 15 page file for Detroit. Both are packed full of information about the airports; how the animated jet ways work, frequently asked questions and tips for getting the most out of the sceneries.

The manual states that the minimum system requirements are a 1.8 GHz processor, 512Mb of RAM and 64Mb video card. In my opinion you will need a slightly higher performance video card to really enjoy the scenery, however the rest of the recommendations are reasonable. The manual also outlines some steps to make sure you are getting the best performance out of your flight simulator.

First Impressions

After initially loading these sceneries, I was very impressed at how great they looked. Although I have never been to Denver or Detroit, my first impression was how real they looked; perhaps this is due to the amount of detail provided in these packages. Everything has been included, even a complete fence at each airport and every lamp post is accurately placed. Also to my surprise, the airports aren’t empty!

Imagine Simulation has included plenty of static aircraft, ground vehicles and even ground crew to give you the feel of actually being there. Initially I wasn’t impressed with the performance, as I was unable to get over 10 frames per second. After some quick support from the developer, we figured out that it was an issue of my computer under-performing and after doing a clean installation of Windows everything was fine. This is not to say that everyone has to reinstall Windows to use these products, it was merely a rare situation that I encountered.

The Airports

KDEN

One thing that can either make or break scenery is textures. Without textures the scenery is dull and boring even with models containing the highest of details. Textures can also provide detail without using performance expensive polygons. The ground textures such as the runways, taxiways and grass look awesome and realistic; however, the building textures that look excellent at long to medium ranges are not as good up close. This is likely a compromise between texture quality and performance that had to be made to ensure that it would run smoothly on a wide range of systems; it would have been nice to provide a choice between low and high quality during the installation.

An upclose look at the buildings and groundcrew

Textures aside, this scenery is amazing. I spent many hours just slewing around the airport gawking at all the details included. The small details include roads that go in and around the airport, street signs, billboards, light posts, pylons and even lots of baggage and cargo containers. The ground vehicles have flashing beacons to make them completely visible, even at night. There are even ground personnel standing around the airport so you are never alone at Denver. The important details aren’t missed either; the terminal is exactly the way it looks in photographs that I have seen, including the amazing white fabric roof over the main terminal. It would have been nice to have semi-transparent terminal windows, so you could look into the terminal as you can in some other sceneries but this is a luxury that I can live without.

Denver Airport

The unique terminal building

I’ve noticed that many scenery add-ons don’t have perimeter fences surrounding the airport but Denver does feature a complete and secure fence. My guess is that many designers stay away from fences because frame rate performance would have to be sacrificed. The fence in Denver doesn’t look great (very low detail) but it sure is nice to be able to tell where the fence is, and also the added security of being in a safe virtual airport.

Another typical feature that is included with many scenery packages these days is animated jetways. This system provides guidance to pilots while parking at the gate in order to make sure the jetway will be able to properly line up with the aircraft door. The Denver jetways work reasonably well for most aircraft, although I did encounter some problems using them with certain add-on aircraft. The developer has advised me that an update should be released shortly to correct the problems with the jetways.

A concourse with daily traffic

Overhead view of jetway and tarmac markings

KDTW

Detroit was also created by the same people who made the Denver scenery (Imagine Simulation) so it borrowed and improved on many aspects of the Denver scenery. You’ll find the same level of detail at this airport as in Denver with a few extras. The terminal design includes glass windows along the roof area and these are transparent, which is a nice touch.

Ladies and Gentlemen....if you look off to the right you will see the Detroit airport

The real airport is also currently undergoing a major construction and renovation project, so there are even cranes included in this scenery and the framework for a new terminal that is being built. Although I must say, I haven’t seen the workers make much progress on that building!

Under construction....

Perimeter fencing.

Northwest Airlines pretty much dominates this airport in the way of traffic, so there are plenty of Northwest aircraft around. Other airlines around DTW include but are not limited to KLM, United and Southwest. The airport also features a few cargo aprons which are home to UPS and Fedex.

Southwest Airlines....note the pylons surrounding this 737

A busy day at the Northwest hub.

I should also mention that the animated jetways work much better in Detroit then they do in Denver, but as previously mentioned, Imagine Simulation will be releasing an update to Denver so that they work just as well there as they do in Detroit.

 

Test System

Athlon XP2500+
Asus A7N8X-E Deluxe
1GB Samsung PC3200
MSI NX6600GT 128MB
Windows XP

Flying Time:
14.5 hours

Frame-rate Performance

As with many other scenery packages, DEN and DTW do not score well in the performance category. On high-end computers you can achieve acceptable frame rates to make flying in and out of Denver and Detroit enjoyable, but on aging computers the performance may vary. I have included a table below to show the difference between the add-on scenery and default scenery (on my computer) so you can judge how well these packages might run on your computer.
  KDEN KDTW
Default 38 - 42 fps 29 - 31 fps
Imagine Sim 10 - 15 fps 9 - 13 fps

* Results recorded using the exact same scene with and without add-on scenery

Conclusion

Despite performance problems, if you have a newer computer with plenty of power, you will be quite satisfied with these packages. These scenery packages are definitely worth trying, especially if you live in the Denver or Detroit areas or have r traveled through these airports.

When I flew into DEN or DTW I got a real sense of being there, and since I haven’t been to either of these cities in real life, it was fun to taxi around and take in the sights of these virtual airports.

What I Like About KDEN and KDTW
  • Attention to detail
  • Great ground textures
  • Lots of static objects including aircraft, ground vehicles and people!
  • Docking system works very well in Detroit

 
What I Don't Like About KDEN and KDTW
  • Building textures look poor up close
  • Taxing on the system, especially on older computers

Printing

If you wish to print this review or read it offline at your leisure,  right click on the link below, and select "save as"

KDEN-KDTW

(adobe acrobat required)

 


Click below to add your comments!

 

Tell A Friend About this Review!

 

Standard Disclaimer
The review above is a subjective assessment of the product by the author. There is no connection between the producer and the reviewer, and we feel this review is unbiased and truly reflects the performance of the product in the simming environment. This disclaimer is posted here in order provide you with background information on the reviewer and connections that may exist between him/her and the contributing party.

© 2005 - AVSIM Online
All Rights Reserved